“I don’t answer questions” is a powerful statement, as you have a right to remain silent. If an officer attempts to stop you on the street, you can simply ask them if you are being arrested or detained. In the event they say no, you can walk off in silence.
If you are detained or arrested by police, they have to immediately inform you as to why you are being detained, then immediately provide you with your rights, which include the right to silence and the right to speak to a lawyer of your choice. Lawyers will advise you NOT to speak to police.
Courts are forbidden from associating silence with guilt or suspicion. Not providing a statement to police is usually in your best interest as anything you say can be used against you as evidence of the offence. If detained, you should give your name and date of birth, but it is typically not recommended to say anything else.
Police can continue to ask you questions and will often use a variety of techniques to try and get you to speak to them, even after you have told them multiple times you do not wish to answer any questions. You can simply reply that you are asserting your right to silence, but understand that does not prohibit them from asking questions, so be prepared to offer that reply over and over.
If you are pulled over in your car under the Highway Traffic Act, police do have the ability to ask you questions you are compelled to answer. These questions MUST be restricted to the driver and must be directly related to the sobriety of the drive, the licensing and insurance of the driver and ownership of the vehicle, and the fitness of the vehicle. Any other questions can only result from a proper arrest or detention, and must follow the same protocol listed above.
Have you have been arrested in Hamilton or the surrounding areas? Visit our Hamilton Criminal Lawyers page to learn more and contact our team.
3 comments
Rustam Tashpulatov
Hello,
would it be a good idea to use this line when performing an equivalent of a first amendment audit in Canada? For example, can you tell an officer that you do not answer questions when asked for an ID just because people phoned that I am standing on a public street where I can legally remain and take pictures and videos of the bank or a refinery?
Thank you,
Rustam
Hardiljit Singh
On 12 th november 2019 i was working renovations in brampton.around 6-6:30 pm the house owner came back getting some stuff from home depot and out of blue he speed up the car towards me and hit me with it and i got run down.the car made a stop after hitting the tree and i came out from underneath the car.after the guy fled in the same car and after i called 911 and the police and ambulance came.the medics cheked me and at my own consent i refused to go
To the hospital though i was bady injured.Cops took me statement and told me to come to div 22 for getting the pictures clicked of my injuries.everything asked i got it done.no further inquiries were made by the police.i followed up couple of times but no results.recently i came to know that the same guy is in jail but i dont know what he did but hes not charged for attempting to kill me thats for sure.what can be done here?
Collett Read LLP
To report a crime, please contact the OPP toll-free at 1-888-310-1122. The police will conduct an investigation, and if they have cause to believe that a crime has been committed, they may charge the individual.